Is “Once Saved, Always Saved” Biblical?
When exploring the depth of Christian teachings, especially regarding the debated topic of “once saved, always saved,” it’s crucial to engage with the breadth of scriptural wisdom and the richness of the theological tradition. This notion, that once we’ve embraced salvation, it can never be forfeited, regardless of our actions or beliefs thereafter, is comforting but oversimplified. The Bible, in its complexity and nuance, offers us a more dynamic understanding of our relationship with God—a relationship marked by freedom, growth, and, yes, the possibility of estrangement. In other words…one CAN lose their salvation.
Listen to the podcast on this subject by clicking below.
Let’s take a closer look at the evidence that challenges the permanence of salvation as a one-off event:
The Bible’s Warnings: The scriptures are filled with cautionary advice, gently reminding us that faith is not a “once and done” affair. For instance, Hebrews 6:4-6 and 2 Peter 2:20-22 starkly warn believers about the dangers of falling away after having experienced the light of Christ. These warnings wouldn’t make sense if our salvation were irrevocably sealed with no action on our part.
Salvation’s Conditions: Numerous passages underscore the need for persistence in our faith journey. Colossians 1:22-23 and John 15:6 don’t just invite but require us to continue in faith, suggesting that our relationship with Christ is active and ongoing, not static.
22 he has now reconciled bin his body of flesh by his death, cin order to present you holy and blameless and dabove reproach before him, 23 eif indeed you continue in the faith, fstable and steadfast, not shifting from gthe hope of the gospel that you heard, which has been proclaimed hin all creation7 under heaven, iand of which I, Paul, became a minister. – Colossians 1:22–23
The Call to Endure: The New Testament doesn’t shy away from calling believers to endurance and perseverance. Verses like Matthew 24:13 and Hebrews 10:26-27 remind us that standing firm in our faith is essential to our salvation. This emphasis on perseverance underlines the possibility of failing to do so.
Real-Life Apostasies: The Bible doesn’t just deal in hypotheticals—it presents actual cases of individuals who have wandered away from their faith, as seen in 1 Timothy 1:19-20 and the parable of the sower (Luke 8:13). These aren’t merely cautionary tales but real examples that apostasy is a genuine risk.
The Significance of Free Will: At the heart of our faith is the gift of choice. This freedom means believers are continually called to choose God, to choose faith, and to choose a life in Christ. It’s a relationship that requires our active participation, not a passive assurance.
In wrestling with these scriptures and ideas, we’re invited into a deeper, more profound understanding of our faith. This perspective isn’t meant to scare us but to sober us with the gravity of our choices and the ongoing nature of our faith journey. It reminds us that salvation is not just a moment of conversion but a daily decision to walk with God, to abide in His love, and to actively participate in the grace He offers.
Understanding salvation in this light doesn’t diminish the power of God’s grace but rather magnifies the beauty of our participation in it. It encourages us to live out our faith with diligence, knowing that our relationship with God is vibrant, alive, and responsive to our choices. Let’s embrace this journey with both its challenges and its profound promises, trusting in God’s guidance and our capacity to remain faithful in His love.
Expanding on the subject of the conditional nature of salvation and the possibility of apostasy within the Christian faith, it’s helpful to draw upon the insights and perspectives of various theologians and pastors throughout Christian history. These figures offer a deeper understanding of how one might interpret the warnings and conditions related to salvation found in Scripture, adding depth and nuance to this theological discussion.
1. Augustine of Hippo
Augustine, a foundational figure in both Western Christianity and Western philosophy, offers valuable insights into the nature of grace, free will, and perseverance. While Augustine is often associated with the doctrines of predestination and irresistible grace, he also emphasized the need for perseverance in faith. In his work “On Rebuke and Grace,” Augustine wrote, “He, therefore, who perseveres to the end is he who has been elected to the end; that is, he who has been elected that he might persevere to the end.”
2. John Wesley
John Wesley, the founder of Methodism, strongly advocated for the idea that salvation could be lost through apostasy. Wesley argued against a once-saved-always-saved position, emphasizing the need for continued faith and holiness. In his sermon “The Danger of Falling,” Wesley stated, “There is no such height or strength of holiness as it is impossible to fall from… the highest saint under heaven can stand only by continual faith in the Son of God, and by the continual supply of his Spirit.”
3. Dietrich Bonhoeffer
Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a German Lutheran pastor and theologian known for his staunch resistance to Nazi dictatorship, introduced the concept of “cheap grace” versus “costly grace.” In his book “The Cost of Discipleship,” Bonhoeffer criticized “cheap grace” as the grace we bestow on ourselves – grace without discipleship, grace without the cross. Bonhoeffer’s critique serves as a powerful reminder of the active and costly nature of true discipleship, implying that genuine faith must be lived out and can indeed be abandoned.
4. A.W. Tozer
A.W. Tozer, an American Christian pastor, author, and spiritual mentor, often spoke on the necessity of a living faith. In his work “The Pursuit of God,” Tozer emphasized the ongoing nature of seeking God, stating, “To have found God and still to pursue Him is the soul’s paradox of love.” This pursuit suggests an active relationship with God, where salvation is not merely a past event but a present, living reality that requires participation and commitment.
5. J.I. Packer
J.I. Packer, an influential evangelical theologian and writer, discussed the balance between divine sovereignty and human responsibility in his book “Evangelism and the Sovereignty of God.” Packer navigated the complex issue of perseverance, noting that while God’s grace is ultimately irresistible, the Bible still calls believers to warn each other against falling away, indicating the real possibility of apostasy.
